In the case of Gilham v Ministry of Justice, Claire Gilham, a District Judge raised concerns about workload and poor management of the courts, before claiming to suffer a detriment as a result of her whistleblowing. The Ministry of Justice claimed that as she was classed as an office holder and not a worker, she was not covered by whistleblowing protection.
In October 2019, the Supreme Court delivered its groundbreaking decision which opens the door to more people obtaining employment protection, if they are treated unfairly or dismissed after making a protected disclosure. The Court ruled that excluding other office holders is a breach of their human rights.
This decision could open the door to other statutory office holders, not currently protected under the whistleblowing legislation, to bring claims. E.g. individuals without contracts of employment such as board members and appointments under the constitution of the organisation.
A person who’s been appointed to a position by a company or organization, but doesn’t have a contract or receive regular payment may be an office holder. This includes:
- statutory appointments, such as registered company directors or secretaries, board members of statutory bodies, or crown appointments
- appointments under the internal constitution of an organisation, such as club treasurers or trade union secretaries
- appointments under a trust deed, such as trustees
- ecclesiastical appointment, such as members of the clergy
Make sure that you have robust whistleblowing policies in place that now apply to ALL individuals protected. If you need a whistleblowing policy or support with management of any grievance or investigation, please get in touch with one of the team on 01924 827869.
References:






